Old-Fashioned

Our Old Fashioned Candy includes nostalgic hard-to-find items from the U.S.A. and Europe - all of them are fondly remembered and therefore always in high demand.
Items: 112 of 39, per page
  • Kits
    • 30% less
    An oldie but goodie. Taffy squares in a variety of flavors.
    • $3.50

    Not rated yet
  • Anise Squares
    • 9% less
    Distinct anise flavored hard candy, an English favorite.
    • $4.99

    Score: 5.00 (votes: 2)
  • Vanilla Bullseye
    • 9% less
    An old time favorite from Baltimore. A vanilla flavored caramel with a soft creamy center.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Chocolate Bullseye
    • 9% less
    An old time favorite from Baltimore, this chocolate flavored caramel has a soft creamy center.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Vanilla Caramel
    • 9% less
    Our oh-so-creamy, vanilla flavored caramel.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Chocolate Caramel
    • 9% less
    Our oh-so-creamy chocolate flavored caramel.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Tootsie Roll
    • 9% less
    Advertising made them well known but their taste made them famous. Small, chewy bits of chocolate candy that make your mouth water.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Assorted Tootsie Roll
    • 9% less
    These chewy bite size morsels include lime, strawberry, cherry and vanilla flavors.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Bit-O-Honey
    • 9% less
    An oldie with an amazing endurance. Everyone remembers the sweet, golden morsels of hard, and chewy honey.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Sesame Honey Crunch
    • 9% less
    The name says it all. This candy has been making crunchy pieces of sesame seed coverd honey for thousands of years. They are as delicious as they sound.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Peanut Butter Bars (bulk)
    • 9% less
    Crispy peanut butter filled candy.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Chick-O-Stick
    • 9% less
    Crisp and crunchy peanut butter with toasted coconut in a distinct orange color.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
Items: 112 of 39, per page
Bestsellers