Old-Fashioned

Our Old Fashioned Candy includes nostalgic hard-to-find items from the U.S.A. and Europe - all of them are fondly remembered and therefore always in high demand.
Items: 112 of 41, per page
Drop items here to shop
Product has been added to your cart
  • Kits
    • 30% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart
    An oldie but goodie. Taffy squares in a variety of flavors.
    • $3.50

    Not rated yet
  • Old-Fashioned Taffy
    • 25% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart

    Made in Texas... Bigger and better! Strips of delicious old time taffy.

    • $1.50

    Not rated yet
  • Anise Squares
    • 9% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart
    Distinct anise flavored hard candy, an English favorite.
    • $4.99

    Score: 5.00 (votes: 2)
  • Vanilla Bullseye
    • 9% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart
    An old time favorite from Baltimore. A vanilla flavored caramel with a soft creamy center.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Chocolate Bullseye
    • 9% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart
    An old time favorite from Baltimore, this chocolate flavored caramel has a soft creamy center.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Vanilla Caramel
    • 9% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart
    Our oh-so-creamy, vanilla flavored caramel.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Chocolate Caramel
    • 9% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart
    Our oh-so-creamy chocolate flavored caramel.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Tootsie Roll
    • 9% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart
    Advertising made them well known but their taste made them famous. Small, chewy bits of chocolate candy that make your mouth water.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Assorted Tootsie Roll
    • 9% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart
    These chewy bite size morsels include lime, strawberry, cherry and vanilla flavors.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Bit-O-Honey
    • 9% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart
    An oldie with an amazing endurance. Everyone remembers the sweet, golden morsels of hard, and chewy honey.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Sesame Honey Crunch
    • 9% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart
    The name says it all. This candy has been making crunchy pieces of sesame seed coverd honey for thousands of years. They are as delicious as they sound.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
  • Peanut Butter Bars (bulk)
    • 9% less
    Drag and drop me to the cart
    Crispy peanut butter filled candy.
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
Items: 112 of 41, per page
Bestsellers
  • Drag and drop me to the cart
    • $1.50

    Not rated yet
    • 25% less
  • Drag and drop me to the cart
    • $3.50

    Not rated yet
    • 30% less
  • Drag and drop me to the cart
    • $4.99

    Score: 2.00 (votes: 2)
    • 9% less
  • Drag and drop me to the cart
    • $4.99

    Score: 5.00 (votes: 2)
    • 9% less
  • Drag and drop me to the cart
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
    • 9% less
  • Drag and drop me to the cart
    • $4.99

    Not rated yet
    • 9% less